The Cool Black Stars Shining on The Poker Face Show

2024 Projects

Poker Face, the hit mystery-of-the-week series created by Rian Johnson and starring Natasha Lyonne, isn’t just known for its clever writing and retro noir vibe, it’s also celebrated for its incredible rotating cast. Among the standout guest stars are many talented Black actors who bring depth, charisma and cool to every episode they touch. From Grammy winners to TV legends, here’s a look at the cool Black stars who’ve appeared on Poker Face and why their roles deserve the spotlight.

Method Man Brings Streetwise Swagger

Cliff “Method Man” Smith is more than just a legendary rapper, he’s become a respected actor, and his guest appearance on Poker Face proves it. Method Man plays a no-nonsense security guard named Taffy in an episode that blends mystery, music and murder. His performance is grounded yet charismatic, giving the episode an extra layer of grit and authenticity.

Method Man’s natural screen presence and deep voice make him a perfect fit for the show’s noir-inspired aesthetic. He brings a cool confidence to every scene and reminds audiences why he’s one of the most versatile performers in entertainment today.

Cynthia Erivo Elevates the Mystery

Tony and Grammy Award-winner Cynthia Erivo brings elegance and intensity to her Poker Face role. As a guest star, Erivo steps into a cerebral episode where her character’s intellect and emotional depth are front and centre. Known for her powerhouse performances in Harriet and The Color Purple, Erivo delivers a nuanced portrayal that blends vulnerability with a razor-sharp edge.

S. Epatha Merkerson

TV royalty S. Epatha Merkerson (Law & Order) brings wisdom and fierce energy to her role. Her decades of experience show through in her commanding screen presence. Whether she’s navigating family secrets or community struggles, Merkerson brings authenticity that grounds the mystery in real-world emotion.

Lil Rel Howery – Charm, Chaos, and Comic Gold

Lil Rel Howery delivers a memorable mix of comedy and cunning in his guest role. Known for his breakout in Get Out and his scene-stealing humour, Howery surprises fans by flexing his dramatic muscles while still keeping his signature comedic edge. His episode adds a layer of levity and mischief, making it a fan favourite.

Dascha Polanco – Street Smart & Stylish

Dominican-American actress Dascha Polanco (Orange Is the New Black) brings toughness and flair to Poker Face. Her character is street-smart, fashion-forward, and not to be underestimated. Polanco commands attention with her natural confidence and layered performance, reminding audiences of her range and screen presence.

Beyond these headliners, Poker Face features a diverse range of Black talent in guest and supporting roles. Whether playing villains, victims, or heroes, these stars bring complexity, culture, and charisma to every frame. This commitment to casting inclusively makes Poker Face not just entertaining, but refreshingly representative of the world we live in.

Rian Johnson’s Poker Face is more than just a throwback detective show—it’s a showcase for some of the finest Black talent in Hollywood today. Whether it’s Method Man’s swag, Cynthia Erivo’s emotional range, or Lil Rel’s humour, these stars are redefining what it means to be cool, clever, and captivating on screen.

If you haven’t tuned in yet, don’t wait. With each episode spotlighting a new mystery and new unforgettable guest stars, you never know who might show up next.